Everything You Need to Know About S-Corps and LLCs

Learn the critical differences between S-Corps and LLCs. Discover whether an S-Corp is an LLC and how to choose between an S-Corp for LLC. Understand S-Corp LLC nuances.

Reviewed and verified by
Sarah Jameson
Senior Editor

Introduction to Business Structures

When starting a new business, choosing the right structure is crucial. Each business structure—such as sole proprietorships, partnerships, corporations, and limited liability companies—has unique implications for liability, taxation, and governance.

Factors to Consider

  • Liability Protection: Some structures provide limited liability, shielding personal assets from business debts.

  • Taxation: Different structures have varying tax obligations and advantages.

  • Management and Governance: Structures may dictate how decisions are made and who holds authority.

Understanding these factors is essential for selecting the optimal business structure. Each option offers specific benefits and challenges based on individual business needs.

Defining S-Corp and LLC

S-Corp:

An S-Corporation, or S-Corp, is a special type of corporation created through an IRS tax election. By electing S-Corp status, businesses can pass corporate income, losses, deductions, and credits through to shareholders for federal tax purposes. Shareholders of S-Corps report their share of income and losses on their personal tax returns, avoiding double taxation on corporate income.

LLC:

A Limited Liability Company, or LLC, is a flexible business structure that combines the liability protection of a corporation with the tax efficiencies and operational flexibility of a partnership. LLC owners, known as members, are shielded from personal liability for business debts and claims, ensuring personal assets are protected.

Key Similarities Between S-Corp and LLC

Both S-Corps and LLCs offer several benefits that appeal to small business owners and entrepreneurs. They each provide limited liability protection, meaning the personal assets of members or shareholders are generally protected from business debts and claims. Both structures allow pass-through taxation, where business income is reported on the owners’ personal tax returns, avoiding double taxation. Each entity permits the establishment of management flexibility, allowing owners to oversee daily operations or appoint managers. Additionally, both can enjoy perpetual existence, ensuring continuity despite changes in ownership or membership.

Ownership and Management Structures

S-Corps

  • Ownership: Limited to 100 shareholders who must be U.S. citizens or residents. Family members count as a single shareholder.

  • Management: Directors manage the corporation and appoint officers. Shareholders have voting rights on major decisions but do not directly manage.

LLCs

  • Ownership: No restrictions on the number of members. Members can be individuals, corporations, other LLCs, or foreign entities.

  • Management: Flexibility in management structures. Can be either member-managed where all owners participate, or manager-managed where appointed managers run operations. Members have operational input based on the operating agreement.

Taxation Differences

Understanding the taxation differences between S-Corps and LLCs is crucial for business owners.

S-Corps:

  • Avoid double taxation.

  • Income, deductions, and credits are passed through to shareholders.

  • Shareholders report income on personal tax returns.

  • Wages paid to owners are subject to employment tax.

LLCs:

  • Flexible taxation options.

  • Can be taxed as sole proprietorships, partnerships, or corporations.

  • Self-employment tax on net earnings if treated as a partnership.

  • Can elect S-Corp taxation to benefit from reduced self-employment taxes.

Tax strategies depend on business goals and structure. Consulting a tax professional is advisable.

Liability Protection

S-Corps and LLCs both provide liability protection for their owners. This means personal assets, such as personal savings or home, are generally protected from business debts and legal claims.

  • LLC: Offers flexibility; members aren’t personally liable.

  • S-Corp: Shareholders’ liability is limited to their investment.

Key differences include:

  • Management Structure:

    • LLC: Managed by members or managers.

    • S-Corp: Requires a board of directors and officers.

  • Operational Formalities:

    • LLC: Requires minimal formalities.

    • S-Corp: Must follow corporate formalities like annual meetings.

Formation and Ongoing Compliance Requirements

Forming an S-Corp or LLC involves several steps.

Formation Steps for S-Corp

  1. File Articles of Incorporation: Submit to the state.

  2. Issue Stock: Distribute to shareholders.

  3. Adopt Bylaws: Outline management and regulations.

  4. Form a Board: Appoint directors and officers.

Formation Steps for LLC

  1. File Articles of Organization: Submit to the state.

  2. Create an Operating Agreement: Outline management roles.

  3. Obtain Licenses: Fulfill local requirements.

Ongoing Compliance for Both

  • Annual Reports: File with the state.

  • Meeting Minutes: Maintain accurate records.

  • Taxes: Ensure timely filings and payments.

  • State Fees: Pay required fees and renew licenses.

Profit Distribution and Compensation

When comparing S-Corps and LLCs, it’s important to understand how profits are distributed and compensations are handled:

S-Corps

  • Salary and Dividends: S-Corp owners often receive a salary and dividends. The salary is subject to payroll taxes, while dividends are not.

  • Reasonable Compensation: The IRS mandates that S-Corp owners must receive reasonable compensation for services rendered, based on market rates.

LLCs

  • Member Distributions: LLC profits are distributed among members according to their ownership percentages, unless specified otherwise in the operating agreement.

  • Self-Employment Tax: LLC members typically pay self-employment tax on their share of profits as they are treated as self-employed individuals.

Advantages of Choosing an S-Corp

Choosing an S-Corp offers several benefits that may make it an attractive option for business owners:

  • Pass-Through Taxation: S-Corps allow business income, losses, deductions, and credits to pass through to shareholders, avoiding double taxation.

  • Self-Employment Tax Savings: Business owners can save on self-employment taxes by splitting income between salary and distributions.

  • Limited Liability Protection: Shareholders are protected from personal liability for business debts and claims.

  • Credibility and Perpetual Existence: S-Corps generally have more credibility with investors and lenders, and they continue to exist beyond the involvement of original owners.

  • Profit Distribution Flexibility: Profits can be distributed based on investment, not necessarily ownership percentage.

Advantages of Choosing an LLC

  1. Limited Liability Protection

    • Personal assets are safeguarded from business debts and lawsuits.
  2. Pass-Through Taxation

    • Profits and losses are reported on personal income tax returns, avoiding double taxation.
  3. Flexibility

    • Management structure can be customized; no board of directors required.
  4. Simplicity

    • Less paperwork and fewer formal requirements compared to corporations.
  5. Credibility

    • LLC status can enhance business credibility with customers and partners.
  6. Profit Distribution

    • Members can distribute profits flexibly regardless of ownership percentages.
  7. State Flexibility

    • Formation rules are state-specific, allowing for strategic planning.

Scenarios Favoring S-Corp

Professionals considering an S-Corp should examine specific conditions. S-Corp status is notably advantageous when:

  • Owners seek salary and dividend distribution flexibility, offering tax-saving potential.

  • Earnings exceed reasonable salary levels, benefiting from lower self-employment tax on dividends.

  • Business owners prefer limited liability with corporation-level structure, aiding in asset protection.

  • Companies plan to attract investors; S-Corps can issue stock, facilitating capital raising.

  • State laws impose excessive LLC fees, making S-Corp status financially prudent.

  • Firms expect employee growth, providing better options for employee benefits and stock options.

Scenarios Favoring LLC

An LLC is optimal for various scenarios. This structure is beneficial when:

  • Owners seek flexibility in management and profit distribution.

  • Members wish to avoid double taxation associated with C-Corporations.

  • Protection from personal liability is a priority, separating personal and business assets.

  • There are plans for simplified administrative requirements and fewer formalities compared to corporations.

  • Businesses operate mostly in a sole-owner or multi-member arrangement.

  • The company anticipates no need to issue stock or go public.

  • Members require flexibility in employment tax treatments.

  • Frequent changes in ownership are expected.

How to Choose the Right Structure for Your Business

To determine the appropriate structure for a business, several factors must be evaluated:

  1. Liability Protection:

    • S-Corps offer limited liability protection.

    • LLCs also provide limited liability protection.

  2. Tax Considerations:

    • S-Corps allow pass-through taxation.

    • LLCs also benefit from pass-through taxation but with more flexibility.

  3. Management and Control:

    • S-Corps are subject to more rigid managerial structures.

    • LLCs offer flexible management structures.

  4. Compliance Requirements:

    • S-Corps adhere to more stringent regulatory requirements.

    • LLCs have fewer ongoing compliance obligations.

  5. Investor Considerations:

    • S-Corps have restrictions on the number and type of shareholders.

    • LLCs have fewer restrictions on membership and investor types.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

When managing an S-Corp or LLC, sidestepping common errors is crucial. Below are some frequent pitfalls:

  • Improper Classification: Mixing up S-Corp and LLC statuses can lead to tax and legal complications.

  • Inadequate Record-Keeping: Lack of meticulous records can result in audits and financial discrepancies.

  • Failure to Follow Formalities: Not adhering to corporate formalities can lead to piercing the corporate veil.

  • Overlooking State Requirements: Ignoring state-specific regulations can cause legal issues or fines.

  • Poor Distribution Management: Inappropriate handling of profit distributions may trigger IRS scrutiny.

  • Neglecting Tax Deadlines: Missing tax filing and payment deadlines can incur penalties.

Brushing up on regulations and seeking expert advice can help avoid these mistakes.

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Choosing between an S-Corp and an LLC depends on various factors, including business goals and financial implications. Both structures offer liability protection and flexible taxation options. Key considerations include:

  1. Taxation:

    • S-Corporations offer pass-through taxation but with specific IRS criteria.

    • LLCs provide flexibility, allowing classification as a sole proprietorship, partnership, or corporation.

  2. Management and Ownership:

    • S-Corps have strict ownership restrictions.

    • LLCs offer fewer formalities and more flexible management structures.

  3. Formation and Compliance:

    • S-Corps require more documentation and adherence to corporate formalities.

    • LLCs are easier to set up and maintain, with minimal compliance requirements.

Evaluate these aspects to align with business objectives.

Form your LLC in 10 minutes or less
Express same-day state filing
Includes Operating Agreement
Includes Banking Resolution
Includes EIN
$299 + state fee
Start your business
Get a Registered Agent
Get the address immediately
Get started
$100/year